Skip to content
Rockoly
Group of coworkers laughing around a festive dinner table with drinks and a Christmas tree
All articles

100 Holiday Would You Rather Questions for Work

Seasonal & holidays

“Would you rather” is the one party game that needs no supplies, no teams, no screen and no warning. Somebody reads a choice, everybody picks a side, and within a minute two people who have never spoken are arguing about whether a gingerbread house is food. That is the whole job of the first ten minutes of an office holiday party.

These one hundred questions are written for work. Every one of them can be answered by someone who does not celebrate Christmas, does not drink, has no family nearby and has no wish to explain any of that to colleagues. They come in eight rounds, so you can read one round as a warm-up or run several as the main game, and there is a quick-fire list at the end for the chat on a video call.

How to run it in ten minutes

Every line in the rounds below starts with the words “Would you rather.” Read them out that way.

  1. Pick one round, not all eight. Ten questions is a warm-up. Thirty is a game. A hundred is a long evening.
  2. Read the question twice, then count down from three. Everyone answers at once: left hand for the first option, right hand for the second. Answering together stops people from waiting to see what the boss picks.
  3. Ask one person from the smaller side why. The minority always has the better story. Thirty seconds, then move on.
  4. Let people pass. “Neither” is a fine answer, and nobody has to explain it.
  5. Stop while it is still funny. End on a question that split the room down the middle, not on the one where the energy ran out.

In a room with space, skip the hands and have people walk to one side or the other. It gets everyone out of their chairs and mixes up who is standing next to whom, which is most of what an icebreaker is for.

What these questions leave out, on purpose

A holiday question at work can go wrong in ways a July one cannot. The rounds below stay away from five things, and any question you add should too:

  • What people spend. Nothing about the size of a gift, a bonus or a trip.
  • Who people spend the holidays with. Not everyone has a family dinner to go to, and not everyone who does is looking forward to it.
  • What people believe. The questions are about winter, food, time off and the office, so nobody has to say which holiday is theirs.
  • Drinking. No question assumes a glass of anything stronger than cider.
  • Bodies and diets. Food questions are about taste, never about being good or bad in December.

The icebreaker activities guide has the longer version of this rule and sixty questions for the rest of the year.

Round 1: Food and drink

Would you rather…

  1. Give up cookies or give up pie for the whole of December?
  2. Drink only hot chocolate or only apple cider until the new year?
  3. Eat the gingerbread house on day one or keep it on display until February?
  4. Have peppermint in every drink or cinnamon in every meal?
  5. Cook the whole holiday dinner or wash every dish afterward?
  6. Eat fruitcake every day for a week or never taste a candy cane again?
  7. Bring the dish everyone asks the recipe for or the dish that is gone in five minutes?
  8. Own a mug of hot chocolate that never runs out or a cookie tin that refills overnight?
  9. Decorate two hundred sugar cookies or peel potatoes for forty people?
  10. Eat dessert first all month or have breakfast for dinner all month?
  11. Live on leftovers for a week or cook from scratch every night of the break?
  12. Eat only the savory holiday food or only the sweet?
  13. Get the corner piece or the center piece of every tray, forever?
  14. Burn the main dish in front of guests or forget dessert entirely?
  15. Take home the leftovers or take home the recipe?

Round 2: The office in December

Would you rather…

  1. Plan the holiday party or clean up after it?
  2. Wear a light-up sweater to every meeting in December or a Santa hat on every video call?
  3. Hold the party at lunch on a Thursday or after work on a Friday?
  4. Give the toast or run the playlist?
  5. Have your desk decorated by your team without warning or decorate the whole floor yourself?
  6. Win the ugly sweater contest or win the trivia?
  7. Hear holiday music in the office from November 1 or no music at all?
  8. Leave an hour early every Friday in December or take one full extra day off?
  9. Answer every email in rhyme for a week or end every meeting with a jingle?
  10. Sit next to the person who loves karaoke or the person who brought the board games?
  11. Be the one who organizes the gift swap or the one who always forgets it is today?
  12. Have your out-of-office reply written by a colleague or by a five-year-old?
  13. Go to a party in person after a long commute or join one from your couch?
  14. See the year-end meeting replaced by a potluck or cut to ten minutes?
  15. Be handed the microphone with no warning or be handed the cleanup list?

Question 21 has a practical use. If your party has both, the 60 holiday trivia questions for work are ready to read out, with answers.

Round 3: Winter and weather

Would you rather…

  1. Have snow every day of December or no snow at all?
  2. Shovel the driveway or scrape the windshield every morning?
  3. Spend the day sledding or spend it by the fire with a book?
  4. Have cold hands or cold feet all winter?
  5. Build the best snowman on the street or win the snowball fight?
  6. Live where it is always the first snowfall or always the first warm day of spring?
  7. Wear mittens or gloves for the rest of your life?
  8. Be snowed in for a weekend with a full fridge or with fast internet, but not both?
  9. Go ice skating or go skiing, with no lessons first?
  10. Have long nights with clear stars or short nights with gray skies?

Round 4: Movies, music and traditions

Would you rather…

  1. Watch the same holiday movie every night of December or no holiday movies at all?
  2. Live in the small town from a holiday romance or the house from a holiday comedy?
  3. Hear one holiday song on repeat for a day or sing one holiday song to the whole office?
  4. Go caroling door to door or act in the school holiday play?
  5. Put the decorations up on November 1 or not until the week of?
  6. Keep the lights up until March or take them down the day after?
  7. Decorate with colored lights or white lights?
  8. Take the group photo or be in the group photo?
  9. Stay up to midnight on New Year’s Eve or wake up early on New Year’s Day?
  10. Start a new tradition this year or bring back one you dropped?
  11. Have a perfectly decorated home for one day or a slightly festive one all winter?
  12. Send cards by mail or send one very good group text?
  13. Be the narrator of a holiday movie or the comic sidekick?
  14. Host everyone at your place or travel to someone else’s?
  15. Have a quiet holiday with five people or a loud one with fifty?

Video call grid of coworkers in party hats and festive sweaters on a desktop monitor

Round 5: Gifts and wrapping

Would you rather…

  1. Give the perfect gift or receive the perfect gift?
  2. Wrap every gift beautifully or never wrap a gift again?
  3. Receive something handmade or something you would never buy yourself?
  4. Know what every gift is before you open it or be surprised every time?
  5. Open one gift a day for a week or everything at once?
  6. Get a gift you can eat or a gift you can read?
  7. Be the best gift wrapper in the office or the best gift guesser?
  8. Join a gift swap where everything is homemade or one where everything is regifted?
  9. Shop in the first week of November or on the last possible afternoon?
  10. Receive an experience or an object?

Round 6: Travel and time off

Would you rather…

  1. Spend the break somewhere snowy or somewhere with a beach?
  2. Drive six hours or take two flights?
  3. Have a week off with no plans or a week off with every day booked?
  4. Travel on the busiest day of the year or leave two days later and miss the first dinner?
  5. Take a long weekend every month or one long break at the end of the year?
  6. Unplug completely for a week or check messages for ten minutes a day?
  7. Spend the first day back clearing your inbox or in back-to-back meetings?
  8. Take a middle seat on a short flight or an aisle seat on a long one?
  9. Stay in a cabin with no signal or a city hotel with a view?
  10. Come back from the break rested or come back with a great story?

Round 7: Impossible choices

This is the round for a team that already knows each other. Read it last, when people are warmed up. Would you rather…

  1. Have a nose that glows red when you are embarrassed or ears that wiggle when you are bored?
  2. Have tinsel for hair or candy canes for fingers?
  3. Speak only in song titles for a day or only in rhyme?
  4. Share a desk with a snowman or manage a penguin as your intern?
  5. Be stuck inside a snow globe for a day or inside a gingerbread house?
  6. Ride to work in a sleigh or slide to work down a snowy hill?
  7. Wear jingle bells on your shoes all December or on your wrists?
  8. Smell like pine or like cinnamon for the rest of the year?
  9. Be able to wrap any gift in three seconds or untangle any string of lights in three?
  10. Have every door you open play a fanfare or every chair you sit in play a jingle?
  11. Deliver every package in your city in one night or read every card sent this year?
  12. Live at the North Pole with great coworkers or on a tropical island with slow Wi-Fi?
  13. Be followed everywhere by your own small snow cloud or your own spotlight?
  14. Trade jobs for a day with a mall Santa or with the person who drives the ice resurfacer at the rink?
  15. Be able to talk to snowmen or hear what the office plants think of you?

Round 8: The year ahead

A quieter round to end on. Would you rather…

  1. Make one big resolution or ten small ones?
  2. Relive the best day of this year or skip ahead to the best day of next year?
  3. Learn a language or learn an instrument next year?
  4. Know one thing that will happen next year or be surprised by all of it?
  5. Start the year with an empty inbox or a clear desk?
  6. Have a year of new places or a year of new people?
  7. Pick the team’s word of the year or pick the team’s theme song?
  8. Gain one extra hour every day or one extra day every month?
  9. Repeat this year exactly or start next year tomorrow?
  10. End this year with a party or begin the next one with one?

If the last round has people looking back on the year, it leads well into a few year-end office awards.

This or that: 20 quick-fire pairs

For a big group or a short slot, drop the sentence and keep the choice. Read a pair, count to three, everybody answers. Twenty pairs take about three minutes.

  • Cookies or pie
  • Hot chocolate or cider
  • Snow day or sunny day
  • Sweater or scarf
  • Cook or bake
  • Host or guest
  • Movie night or game night
  • Old songs or new songs
  • Fireplace or blanket
  • Peppermint or gingerbread
  • Sledding or skating
  • Card or text
  • Wrapping paper or gift bag
  • Midnight countdown or asleep by ten
  • Leftovers or something fresh
  • Candles or string lights
  • Boots or slippers
  • Road trip or flight
  • Party games or good conversation
  • December or January

Four games to play with the questions

Reading questions aloud is enough for ten minutes. For twenty or thirty, give the answers a score.

  1. Majority rules. Everyone writes down their own answer and then guesses which side the room will pick. Hands up, count, and anyone who called the majority gets a point. Ten questions, highest score wins. It rewards knowing your colleagues instead of knowing facts, which makes it a good partner to a trivia round.
  2. Defend the other side. After the vote, pick one person from each side and give them thirty seconds to argue for the option they did not choose. The room votes again. Any swing is a win for the speaker.
  3. Whose answers are these? Send five questions as a form a few days before the party. On the day, read out one person’s five answers and let the room guess who it is. Ask permission on the form, and only read out the people who said yes.
  4. Split the room. Teams of four write one new question each, aiming for a perfect fifty-fifty split when the whole room votes. The team whose question lands closest to even wins. It is harder than it sounds, and the questions people write about their own office are better than anything on a list.

On a video call

The game works as well on a call as in a room, as long as everyone can answer at the same moment.

  • Chat waterfall. Everyone types 1 or 2 but does not press Enter until you say go. The chat fills at once and nobody copies the first answer.
  • Polls. Load a round into the meeting’s poll tool before the call. The result bars do the counting, and a poll is the easy way to score Majority rules.
  • Camera on, camera off. Option one keeps the camera on, option two turns it off. On a large call the gallery view becomes the bar chart.
  • Props. Ask people to bring a mug and a spoon. Mug up for the first option, spoon up for the second.

On a hybrid call, read the question to the remote side first and take their answer first. The room will always be louder, so the people at home need the head start. There are more formats built for the screen in the 25 virtual holiday party ideas for work teams.

Write a round about your own team

The questions people remember are the ones only your office could answer. Write five of your own from these frames:

  • Would you rather have (the thing your team complains about most) fixed forever or get (a small perk everyone wants)?
  • Would you rather relive (this year’s hardest week) or (this year’s longest meeting)?
  • Would you rather swap desks with (one team) or swap calendars with (another team)?
  • Would you rather bring back (a retired office tradition) or keep (the newest one)?
  • Would you rather have next year’s kickoff in (place one) or (place two)?

Keep them about the work and the building, not about a person. A question that makes one colleague the punchline is a question to cut.

If the questions are the warm-up

A round of questions opens a party. It does not fill one. Ten minutes in, people are talking, and the next thing on the agenda has to be worth staying for.

On Rockoly’s holiday specials, that next thing is a live chef, mixologist or artist leading the whole team on Zoom while a Rockoly host runs the room. Everything each person needs is delivered to their own door before the event, with free shipping in the US, and on the day everyone cooks, mixes or paints the same thing at the same time. The host can run holiday trivia, a scavenger hunt, a Secret Santa reveal or an ugly sweater vote between courses, and customization is free, so tell your event planner which round from this page you want read out while the oven is on. Round 1 suits anything from the baking list, and the questions about dishes and leftovers land best when everyone has flour on their hands.

For a team in one place, the same warm-up works before an in-person team building activity, and if your office is swapping cookies that week, the office cookie exchange guide has the rules and a sign-up sheet.